The Duty to Make Reasonable Adjustments Relating to Disabled Access

Although now replaced by The Equality Act – The Disability Discrimination Act (DDA) came in to force in November 1995 with the final stage relating to disabled access coming in to force in October 2004.

The DDA stated;

“Where a physical feature (for example, one arising from the design or construction of a building or the approach or access to premises) makes it impossible or unreasonably difficult for disabled persons to make use of such a service, it is the duty of the provider of that service to take such steps as it is reasonable”

20 Years of Debate on Reasonable Adjustment

So here we are, nearly 20 years since service providers had a duty to make reasonable adjustments for disabled access, yet still we see inaccessible buildings.

As I wrote in a blog post on wheelchair-ramps.co.uk over 20 years ago;

“Reasonable adjustments is a phrase that if you have not heard yet, you more than likely will do other the coming months. It is the so called “grey area” of the DDA which will surely be a key point for the courts to decide.

What constitutes a reasonable adjustment? – There is no easy answer, but in my personal opinion all cases will be dealt with on an individual basis”

Although worded differently in The Equality Act 2010 – There is still a duty for service and goods providers to make reasonable adjustments relating to disabled access.

Are we any closer to a definitive meaning of Reasonable Adjustment though?

Chapter 5: Reasonable Adjustment
193.Sections 20 and 21 of the Equality Act 2010 require those to whom the provisions apply, including employers, service providers, educational institutions, transport providers, and sports bodies, to “take such steps as it is reasonable to have to take” to avoid putting disabled people at “a substantial disadvantage”264. Failure to comply with this duty is a form of discrimination. The duty is not offered on other grounds and reflects the social model of disability which requires changes to the environment, as well as attitudinal and behavioural changes, if disabled people are to participate in society on an equal basis and with dignity and respect. The precise duty has evolved over time and varies across the different aspects of life with which the Act is concerned, as explained in the box below.
Box 5: The Reasonable Adjustment Duty

In general, the duty to make reasonable adjustments requires the taking of “such steps as it is reasonable to have to take” to avoid a disabled person being put at a “substantial disadvantage” by any of the following:

(a) A “provision, criterion or practice”. This could be, for example, adjusting a uniform or dress policy to accommodate different impairment types.

(b)A physical feature. This could include, for example, steps, parking areas, signage, floor covering, furniture and toilets or washing facilities.

(c)Lack of an auxiliary aid or service. Examples here are providing a specialist piece of equipment, a videophone, or a sign language interpreter.

Adjustments under a) or c) could include making information available in an accessible format. It is not permissible to pass the costs of making an adjustment on to the disabled person.

The duty in employment

Employers are required to meet all three limbs of the duty in respect of disabled job applicants and employees. The duty is ‘reactive’: it requires there to be an identified applicant or employee, and for the employer to know, or be reasonably expected to know, that that person is disabled, and that they are likely to be at the substantial disadvantage without the adjustment.

The duty also applies in respect of some other types of work, such as contract work and barristers.

The duty in respect of premises

Similarly, a controller of let premises or of premises to let is required to react to the needs of tenants, but not to anticipate them. So they may be required to provide a rent agreement in an alternative format such as large print, but are not required to plan for this themselves. Nor do the controllers of premises have to make adjustments to physical features, other than certain auxiliary aids that might otherwise be classified as physical features—such as an entry phone system.

The duty in the provision of services and public functions

Those providing services and exercising public functions are bound by all three requirements. The key difference with employers is that in the case of services and public functions the duty is ‘anticipatory’: it is owed to “disabled persons generally” and requires service providers and those exercising public functions to proactively remove barriers that could put disabled people at a substantial disadvantage without waiting for a disabled person to seek to use their services first.

The duty in schools and further and higher education

The duty on schools and in further and higher education is again ‘anticipatory’. Schools, universities, and higher and further education institutions are required not only to respond to the needs of disabled pupils, but to anticipate access needs of disabled people. Schools are not subject to the requirement to adjust physical features, but they must prepare accessibility strategies and plans to address disadvantages associated with physical features. The only exception is in respect of qualifications and competence standards, which are not subject to the duty to make reasonable adjustments, but instead may need to be justified if they are indirectly discriminatory.

Read more views from parliament.uk relating to Chapter 5: Reasonable Adjustment

Parliament Calls For Code of Practice and Guidance Relating to Reasonable Adjustment Disability

Code of Practice and guidance
226.Clarity is important, but there are ways of clarifying what adjustments are reasonable and what are not, which do not involve either more specific legislation or frequent resort to the courts. The case for better guidance was made forcefully by Muscular Dystrophy UK:

“But why hasn’t the tide turned? Why didn’t every business buy a folding ramp in 2010 and install a hearing loop? Why didn’t the double glazing salesmen suddenly have a special offer on level threshold doorways with an extra discount for lightweight doors? Why didn’t pasta sauce manufacturers demand that the designers of the labels for the jars use a bigger font that’s actually readable? The simple answer is, no one told them to, and no one told them how.

It’s not easy to find an “Accessibility for Dummies” book, even if you look for one. Generic “How to … business” books have very little, if any, information on accessibility. Even if they did, we run into the same questions: What is a “reasonable adjustment” anyway?”

227.The Business Disability Forum agreed that more statutory guidance may be needed to “minimise the need for legal challenge while increasingly removing the barriers disabled people face to equal participation because of their disability.” The RNIB were in favour of statutory guidance as it would “provide significantly more detailed advice as to when the duty arises, what constitutes a reasonable adjustment, what constitutes substantial disadvantage, how the anticipatory duty can be met and what the continuing/evolving nature of the duty means in reality.”353 Witnesses also felt it important that guidance should use examples and explain how cost is taken into account.

228.IPSEA supported using a Code of Practice to be more explicit on what constitutes a reasonable adjustment, and the Bar Council asked for consideration to be given to “augmenting the Codes of Practice” with further examples of reasonable adjustments and to see the Codes taken into account “prior to judicial decision-making.” The University of Leeds argued that: “Alongside the current codes, which integrate guidance on reasonable adjustments into more generic guidance, we suggest that there is a need for a separate code on reasonable adjustments”.

229.Almost all the issues discussed in this chapter were cited as problems that statutory guidance could help with: the Nuffield Council on Bioethics felt that practical guidance would help people understand adjustments for people with dementia; the Newcastle Society for Blind People wanted guidance on the role of cost in deciding what is reasonable; and Muscular Dystrophy UK wanted examples of best practice and how to complain if reasonable adjustments were not made. The proactive nature of the duty had recently been put in doubt by a case in the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT), Griffiths v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, which equated disability-related leave with sickness absence not related to disability. The Business Disability Forum felt that this suggested that “if a policy, procedure or criteria applies to everyone it cannot place a disabled person at a substantial disadvantage”. The Bar Council and Disability Rights UK both wanted clarity on this matter, particularly as the judgment appeared to contradict the relevant Code of Practice. Since our call for evidence, the Court of Appeal has ruled on Griffiths and overturned the EAT decision, holding that “The duty arises once there is evidence that the arrangements placed the disabled person at a substantial disadvantage because of her disability.” It is nevertheless of concern that 20 years on from the original Disability Discrimination Act this question required a Court of Appeal judgment to set it right.

230.We agree that guidance is the appropriate means by which to provide the clarity that our witnesses sought. Given the considerable problems outlined above with compliance, this guidance must have teeth, and we agree with the University of Leeds that the best way to achieve this is by a Code of Practice. While keeping in mind the caution, offered by the Association of National Specialist Colleges, that guidance and attempts to be “over explicit” can “go out of date quite quickly”, we believe that the EHRC, whose guidance is already well respected, is ideally placed to manage this risk.

231.The Equality and Human Rights Commission should prepare a specific Code of Practice on reasonable adjustments to supplement the existing Equality Act Codes. This would provide an appropriate balance between flexibility and clarity. Without it there is a real risk of employers and service providers acting illegally because of ignorance of their obligations.

232.We have explained in Chapter 3 how Ministers have in three cases inexplicably refused to lay draft Codes of Practice before Parliament and make Orders giving them statutory force. This cannot be allowed to happen in the case of a new Code on reasonable adjustments.

233.Of course, guidance is only as good as the use to which it is put. We heard some good examples of organisations that used membership structures to promote information on the requirements of the Equality Act. Marie-Claire Frankie, giving evidence for the National Association of Licensing and Enforcement Officers (NALEO), told us that Sheffield Council used its regular newsletter to taxi drivers to detail successful prosecutions under the Act and remind drivers “of what they should do and that their licences could be at risk if they did not take guide dogs, for example.” Ms Frankie also spoke about how NALEO kept their members up to date:

“In relation to case law and stated cases that come up, NALEO, as an organisation, circulates that to all the members, so all 600 members then get notification of this case, the requirements and all the commentary from it. It is for them to feed that into their day-to-day licensing role.”

234.Alongside the new Code, the Equality and Human Rights Commission should produce, in consultation with organisations of and representing disabled people, industry-specific guidance on reasonable adjustment. Where appropriate this should be done in partnership with relevant professional and regulatory bodies. Regular updates on case law developments will be essential to the effectiveness of these guides, and should be provided by the EHRC.

Source of the above – The Equality Act 2010: the impact on disabled people

Contains Parliamentary information licensed under the Open Parliament Licence v3.0.

Portable Wheelchair Ramps
Available to buy Online.

Recent Posts

Buyers Guide For Wheelchair Ramps : Guide on Buying a Wheelchair Ramp for Personal Use

Recommended Wheelchair Ramps

A wide range of portable wheelchair ramps available to buy Online and have delivered within 1-2 business days*



* UK Mainland, 99% of the time and subject to availability.


©2024 - This website is managed and maintained by TJS Marketing Ltd.